Gel Manicure vs Shellac: The Ultimate Comparison
When it comes to long-lasting and durable manicures, gel manicure and shellac are two popular options. Both offer a glossy and chip-resistant finish that can last for weeks. However, there are some key differences between the two. In this article, we will compare gel manicure and shellac in various aspects to help you make an informed decision.
1. Application Process
Gel manicure involves applying a base coat, several layers of gel polish, and a top coat. Each layer is cured under a UV or LED lamp. On the other hand, shellac is a hybrid polish that combines the features of gel and traditional nail polish. It requires a base coat, two layers of color, and a top coat, with each layer cured under a UV lamp.
Both gel manicure and shellac require careful application to ensure a smooth and even finish. However, gel manicure may require more layers and curing time compared to shellac.
2. Durability
Both gel manicure and shellac are known for their long-lasting properties. They provide a chip-resistant and glossy finish that can last up to two weeks or more. However, gel manicure tends to be slightly more durable than shellac due to its thicker formula.
Gel manicure is less prone to chipping and peeling, making it a popular choice for those who want a manicure that can withstand daily activities and chores.
3. Removal Process
Removing gel manicure and shellac require a similar process. Both involve soaking the nails in acetone to break down the polish. However, gel manicure may take longer to remove as it has more layers to dissolve.
It is important to note that proper removal techniques should be followed to avoid damaging the natural nails. It is recommended to seek professional help or use a gel polish removal kit for safe and effective removal.
4. Nail Health
Both gel manicure and shellac can potentially weaken the nails if not applied and removed properly. The curing process and the use of acetone during removal can cause dryness and brittleness.
However, shellac is generally considered to be less damaging to the nails as it is thinner and requires less filing during the removal process. Gel manicure, on the other hand, may require more filing to remove the layers of gel polish, which can result in thinning of the natural nails.
5. Color Selection
Gel manicure offers a wider range of colors and finishes compared to shellac. Gel polish brands often release new collections with trendy and vibrant shades. Additionally, gel manicure allows for nail art and intricate designs due to its thicker consistency.
Shellac, on the other hand, offers a more limited color selection but still includes a variety of classic and timeless shades.
6. Cost
In general, gel manicure tends to be more expensive than shellac. Gel manicure requires additional steps and products, such as a base coat and top coat, which can increase the overall cost.
Shellac, being a hybrid polish, is often priced lower than gel manicure. However, the cost may vary depending on the salon and location.
7. Maintenance
Both gel manicure and shellac require some maintenance to prolong their longevity. It is recommended to apply cuticle oil regularly to keep the nails hydrated and prevent lifting or peeling.
Additionally, it is important to avoid using the nails as tools and to wear gloves while doing household chores to protect the manicure from excessive wear and tear.
8. Removal Time
As mentioned earlier, gel manicure may take longer to remove compared to shellac due to the additional layers. On average, gel manicure removal can take around 15-20 minutes, while shellac removal can be done within 10-15 minutes.
However, it is important to note that the removal time can vary depending on the thickness of the layers and the technique used.
Conclusion
Both gel manicure and shellac offer long-lasting and durable manicures. Gel manicure is slightly more durable and offers a wider range of colors and finishes. However, it requires more layers and curing time, and the removal process may take longer. Shellac, on the other hand, is thinner and generally less damaging to the nails. It offers a more limited color selection but is often priced lower. Ultimately, the choice between gel manicure and shellac depends on personal preferences and priorities.
